Poor Phil's Shell Bar Menu (Update 2025)
Poor Phil's Shell Bar, located in Oak Park, IL, is a casual American seafood spot offering a wide range of delicious dishes. From the flavorful Po'Phils N'awlins Gumbo to the creamy New England Clam Chowder, the menu here is sure to satisfy seafood lovers. The Lump Crabcake and Garlic Snowclaws are standout options, showcasing the restaurant's knack for preparing seafood with a twist. Customers rave about the lobster bisque, shrimp, and oysters, praising the friendly atmosphere and attentive service. The extensive beer selection, perfectly chilled and served, pairs perfectly with the tasty appetizers like hot wings and fries. The clean, themed bathrooms add an extra touch to the dining experience. Overall, Poor Phil's Shell Bar is a hidden gem with delicious food, great service, and a cozy ambiance.
Hot Soups & Warm Snax
Po'Phils N'awlins Gumbo
spicy chicken, smoked andouille sausage, celery, onion, green pepper, okra, with rice!
New England Clam Chowder
the creamy white one, clam, potato, onion, bacon!
American Chili
chunky ground beef, tomato, onion, celery, kidney bean
New York Chili
topped w/cheddar sour cream, green onion!
Pedrozoup
a changin 'selection!
Lump Crabcake
lump-crab cake, litely-fried baby field greens, balsamic vinaigrette creamy garlic-horseradish dip!
Garlic Fingers
(when available), bite-size blue-crab claws, garlic butter saute!
Garlic Snowclaws
eight snow crab claws garlic butter sauté!
Shrimp'n Suds
six tail-on w/cocktail sauce beer-battered or tempura!
Garlic Mussels
white wine steamed, garlic bread!
Saloon Soups
Warm Seafood Snax
Barroom-Basket-Case-Wings
mild, hot, or barbeque w/celery & bleu cheese dressing!
Chicken Strips
buttermilk-battered, litely-fried, sweet baby rays barbeque sauce!
Mozzarella Marinara
breaded'n litely-fried, ranch & marinara sides!
Sweet Potato Fries
side'a ranch!
HummusDip
chilled hummus dip, cucumber, tomato, warm pita bread!
Pedroz'Shrimp Ceviche
marinated shrimp, lime juice tomato, avocado, red onion jalapeño'n cilantro tortilla dippin'chips!
Shell-on-Shrimp-on-Ice
6 w/cocktail sauce
Snow-Crab-Claws-on-Ice
8 w/mustard/mayo
Chilled Snax & Cool Salads
Chilled Seafood Snax
Crabbylobster Salad
half'a seafood-stuffed lobster side'a mustard/mayo, mixed greens dressing choice, served chilled!
Firecracker Chickensalad
spicy buffalo-fried chicken tenders hot or mild, romaine & iceberg tomato, green pepper, carrot cucumber, snap peas blue cheese crumble dressing choice!
Phils Cobb
diced chicken'n egg blue cheese, bacon, tomato romaine, iceberg, dressing choice!
Nutty Gorgonzola
gorgonzola cheese, spinach greens, grape tomatoes, red grapes, chopped walnuts, dressing choice!
Mandarinchicken
grilled chicken, mandarin oranges baby greens, tomato, snow peas rice noodles, almonds sesame ginger dressing!
ChickenCaesar
grilled'n chilled chicken romaine, tomato wedges shredded parmesan caesar dressing, croutons!
A Nice Little Salad
mixed greens, tomato wedges green pepper, cumcumber, carrot dressing choice!
Fintastic Fish-n-Chips
atlantic cod, beer-battered-fried tartar sauce, fries!
Shrimp Basket
tail-on shrimp, breaded or tempura litely-fried, cocktail sauce, fries!
CrawDaddy Etouffe
big bowl'a spicy crawfish, spanish rice celery, green pepper, onion, garlic bread!
Shrimp Creole
big bowl'a spiced tail-on shrimp, bed'a rice green pepper, onion, celery, garlic bread!
Jambalaya
seasoned chicken & andouille sausage, bed'a rice tomato, green pepper, onion, celery, garlic bread!
Philz'fishTacos
3 corn tempura cod tacos, spanish rice diced onion, tomato, cucumber, shredded cabbage cilantro, creamy garlic-horseradish!
Sea & Shell
Bowls & Baskets
Snow Crab Legs
Live Maine Lobster
King Crab Legs
Fish-n-Cheddar
atlantic cold-water cod beer-battered-fried, cheddar cheese lettuce, tomato, tartar sauce, brioche roll!
Grilled Salmon
arm-raised atlantic salmon smoked spanish paprika aioli lettuce, tomato, red onion, brioche roll!
Grilled Tuna
south-pacific yellowfin tuna seared (very rare) smoked spanish paprika aioli, lettuce, tomato, red onion, brioche roll!
Steamed Shellfish Dinners
Seafood Sandwiches
LobsterRoll
creamy maine lobster salad celery, onion, pepper, fresh dill soft butter-toasted lobster roll, wasabi-mayo, choice'a side, served chilled!
Cattyboy
blackened catfish lettuce, tomato, thin red onion, garlic-mayo, side' a spicy jardinière!
Buffalo'Boy
buffalo chicken strips, hot or mild blue cheese dressing, blue cheese-crumble lettuce & tomato!
Shrimpy'Boy
tempura shrimp, litely-fried lettuce, tomato, thin red onion, wasabi-mayo!
Sandwiches
Po'philz Po'boyz
Da'Bomb
cheddar, bacon, mushroom, lettuce, tomato, grilled onion, ketchup, mayo!
Bluesburger
bleu cheese mayo, lettuce, tomato, red onion!
GuacaBurger
swiss cheese guacamole, lettuce, tomato, red onion!
Texas Bar-BQ
cheddar cheese, barbeque sauce, fried onions, lettuce, tomato!
Ya'gotta Luv'a Murphyburger
grilled third-pound seasoned burger, choice'a cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, ketchup, grilled onion' n pickle, sesame bun!
Barroom Burgers
Philz' Sandwich Classics
Redskins & Corn Cob
Mashed Sweet Potatoes
Tater Tots
Mac'n cheese
French fries
Cole Slaw
Steamed broccoli
Creamed spinach
Chilled fruit
Cottage Cheese
Lavalicious
rich chocolate cake, chocolate fudge-filled, served warm! side'a petersen vanilla ice cream!
Lime Is On My Side
key lime cheesecake, tart & creamy vanilla crumb crust, whipped cream, almond slices!
Honey Mediterranean Cheesecake
wildflower honey cheesecake, touch'a ricotta, crunchy layer'a salted honey toasted pistachios & almonds, vanilla mousse top'd!
Granny's Sauced
rich godiva cheesecake, milk chocolate mousse chunks, chocolate ganache & chocolate whipped cream!
Side
Cakes & Creams
Hot Fudge Turtle Sundae
petersen vanilla ice cream, hot caramel & hot fudge, w.c., pecans, cherry!
Old Fashioned Hot Fudge Sundae
petersen vanilla, hot fudge, w.c., chopped nuts, cherry!
Shakes & Malts
petersen vanilla ice cream with chocolate, strawberry, banana, mango or lime! w.c., cherry!
Chicago Cold Cows
petersen vanilla ice cream in'a black cow (root beer), brown cow (coke), ginger cow (ginger ale) or holy cow (sprite)!
Scoop an'a Squirt
scoop'a petersen vanilla ice cream an'a squirt' a chocolate, hot fudge or caramel!
Solo Scoopo
petersen 18% vanilla ice cream
Coke
diet coke, sprite, ginger ale, tonic or soda water!
Sprecher root beer, on draft
Raspberry Lemonade
lemonade, swampwater, orange, grapefruit, tomato, apple, pineapple or cranberry juice!
Raspberry Iced Tea
Iced Tea or Iced Coffee
Milk
whole or skim
LaCroix sparkling water
Bottle Spring Water
Virgin Daiquiris
pint'a frozen'slushy, strawberry, banana, mango or traditional lime!
Virgin Smoothies
freezin'island oasis yogurt with above flavors!
Sundaes & Shakes
Coke & Coffee
Philz'hot
hot tea, individual pot, fresh ground bottomless coffee, togo hot coffee or hot tea